pygatt подключается, но не может подписаться, а bleak подключается и может подписаться: почему bleak не воспроизводится с помощью pygatt?

Я пытаюсь подписаться на одну характеристику на устройстве BLE. С помощью bleak я могу подключиться к устройству, а затем написать/подписаться на характеристики. С практически идентичным кодом, использующим pygatt, я могу подключиться к тому же устройству с помощью моего ключа BLED112, но не могу писать/подписываться на ту же характеристику.

bleak тестовая программа:

import sys
import os
import asyncio
import aioconsole


from bleak import BleakClient


ADDRESS = '28686572-5A71-435E-952A-6F4292F5B04A'
#ADDRESS = '00:55:DA:B7:98:9C'
CHARACTERISTIC_UUID = '273e0003-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358'

if len(sys.argv) == 3:
    ADDRESS = sys.argv[1]
    CHARACTERISTIC_UUID = sys.argv[2]


def notification_handler(sender, data):
    """Simple notification handler which prints the data received."""
    print("{0}: {1}".format(sender, data))


async def run(address):

    async with BleakClient(address) as client:

        await client.connect()
        print("Is connected")

        # start notifications on control characteristic
        await client.start_notify('273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358', notification_handler)
        # write to control handle, set preset to 21
        await client.write_gatt_char('273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358', bytearray([0x04, 0x70, 0x32, 0x31, 0x0a]), False)
        # write to control handle get device info
        await client.write_gatt_char('273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358', bytearray([0x03, 0x76, 0x31, 0x0a]), False)
        # write to control handle for resume
        await client.write_gatt_char('273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358', bytearray([0x02, 0x64, 0x0a]), False)
        # start notifications on TP9
        await client.start_notify('273e0003-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358', notification_handler)
        # wait for input
        await aioconsole.ainput('Running: Press a key to quit')
        await client.stop_notify('273e0003-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358')


if __name__ == "__main__":

    os.environ["PYTHONASYNCIODEBUG"] = str(1)
    loop = asyncio.get_event_loop()
    loop.run_until_complete(run(ADDRESS))

Выход:

$ python3 bleaktest.py                                         
Is connected
13: bytearray(b'\x08{"rc":0}\x00\x00\x00\x00\x00\x00\x00\x00\x00\x00\x00')
13: bytearray(b'\x10{"ap":"headset",\x00\x00\x00')
13: bytearray(b'\x13"sp":"Blackcomb_rev')
13: bytearray(b'\x03B",":"Blackcomb_rev')
13: bytearray(b'\x10"tp":"consumer",rev')
13: bytearray(b'\x0c"hw":"10.6",er",rev')
13: bytearray(b'\x07"bn":2,0.6",er",rev')
13: bytearray(b'\x0e"fw":"1.0.21",",rev')
13: bytearray(b'\r"bl":"1.0.0",,",rev')
13: bytearray(b'\x07"pv":1,.0.0",,",rev')
13: bytearray(b'\x07"rc":0}.0.0",,",rev')
Running: Press a key to quit
13: bytearray(b'\x08{"rc":0}0.0",,",rev')
31: bytearray(b'\x00\x00\x80\x08\x00z\xa8\xdfL@\x00\xa8!\xb6p\xa0\x00hA\x92')
31: bytearray(b'\x00\x01\x9d0\x00]q\x86\xb5\xb0\x00+\xaf\x96\xf3#\x1a\x00\t\x88')
31: bytearray(b'\x00\x02\x1bh\x04\x00\x06\x14\x18\t\xe8\x00\x05&\x13\xdc%\x00\x01\x97')
...
31: bytearray(b'\x00\x19_\xf1\x85\x9e\xc0\x00GP\xe9\xcb@\x00\t\x9c\xaf\x11\x15\xe4')
...

Как видно из вывода, запись прошла успешно из-за дескрипторов ответов. И подписки явно функциональны, учитывая ответы как контрольной характеристики, так и вторичной характеристики.

pygatt тестовая программа:

import pygatt
import time
from binascii import hexlify

from pygatt.backends.backend import BLEAddressType



def handle_data(handle, data):
    """
    handle -- integer, characteristic read handle the data was received on
    raw_value -- bytearray, the data returned in the notification
    """

    print(hexlify(data))

#adapter = pygatt.GATTToolBackend('hci0') linux backend
adapter = pygatt.BGAPIBackend()

try:
    adapter.start()
    device = adapter.connect('00:55:DA:B7:98:9C', address_type = BLEAddressType.public)
    print("Is connected")
    # start notifications on control characteristic
    device.subscribe('273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358', callback = handle_data, wait_for_response = True)
    # write to control handle, set preset to 21
    device.char_write('273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358', bytearray([0x04, 0x70, 0x32, 0x31, 0x0a]), wait_for_response = True)
    # write to control handle get device info
    device.char_write('273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358', bytearray([0x03, 0x76, 0x31, 0x0a]), wait_for_response = True)
    # write to control handle for resume
    device.char_write('273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358', bytearray([0x02, 0x64, 0x0a]), wait_for_response = True)
    time.sleep(5)
    # subscribe to eeg characteristic
    device.subscribe('273e0003-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358', callback = handle_data, indication = False, wait_for_response = True)
    time.sleep(5)
finally:
    print("Adapter stopped")
    adapter.stop()

Выход:

$ python3 pygatttest.py
Is connected
Adapter stopped

Программа pygatt может подключиться к устройству (я вижу, как световой индикатор меняет состояние с мигающего на постоянное), но подписка не проходит. Я не знаю, работает ли char_write, потому что я не получаю уведомления о возврате. Я пытаюсь использовать модуль logging, чтобы узнать больше в комментариях ниже.

Обновлен вывод с включенным logging:

$ python3 pygatttest.py    
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Initialized new BGAPI backend
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Auto-detecting serial port for BLED112
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.util:Found 4 serial USB devices
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.util:Checking serial USB device: /dev/cu.Bluetooth-Incoming-Port - n/a
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.util:Checking serial USB device: /dev/cu.usbmodem11 - Low Energy Dongle - CDC data
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.util:USB device: Low Energy Dongle - CDC data VID=0x2458 PID=0x0001 on /dev/cu.usbmodem11
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found BLED112 on serial port /dev/cu.usbmodem11
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Resetting and reconnecting to device for a clean environment
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Opening connection to serial port (attempt 1)
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Auto-detecting serial port for BLED112
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.util:Found 4 serial USB devices
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.util:Checking serial USB device: /dev/cu.Bluetooth-Incoming-Port - n/a
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.util:Checking serial USB device: /dev/cu.usbmodem11 - Low Energy Dongle - CDC data
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.util:USB device: Low Energy Dongle - CDC data VID=0x2458 PID=0x0001 on /dev/cu.usbmodem11
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found BLED112 on serial port /dev/cu.usbmodem11
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Opening connection to serial port (attempt 1)
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Auto-detecting serial port for BLED112
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.util:Found 3 serial USB devices
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.util:Checking serial USB device: /dev/cu.Bluetooth-Incoming-Port - n/a
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Failed to open serial port
Traceback (most recent call last):
  File ".../pygatt/backends/bgapi/bgapi.py", line 171, in _open_serial_port
    serial_port = self._serial_port or self._detect_device_port()
  File ".../pygatt/backends/bgapi/bgapi.py", line 147, in _detect_device_port
    raise BGAPIError("Unable to auto-detect BLED112 serial port")
pygatt.backends.bgapi.exceptions.BGAPIError: Unable to auto-detect BLED112 serial port
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Opening connection to serial port (attempt 2)
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Auto-detecting serial port for BLED112
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.util:Found 3 serial USB devices
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.util:Checking serial USB device: /dev/cu.Bluetooth-Incoming-Port - n/a
...
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Failed to open serial port
Traceback (most recent call last):
  File ".../pygatt/backends/bgapi/bgapi.py", line 171, in _open_serial_port
    serial_port = self._serial_port or self._detect_device_port()
  File ".../pygatt/backends/bgapi/bgapi.py", line 147, in _detect_device_port
    raise BGAPIError("Unable to auto-detect BLED112 serial port")
pygatt.backends.bgapi.exceptions.BGAPIError: Unable to auto-detect BLED112 serial port
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Opening connection to serial port (attempt 3)
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Auto-detecting serial port for BLED112
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.util:Found 4 serial USB devices
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.util:Checking serial USB device: /dev/cu.Bluetooth-Incoming-Port - n/a
...
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.util:Checking serial USB device: /dev/cu.usbmodem11 - Low Energy Dongle - CDC data
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.util:USB device: Low Energy Dongle - CDC data VID=0x2458 PID=0x0001 on /dev/cu.usbmodem11
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found BLED112 on serial port /dev/cu.usbmodem11
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Running receiver
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Disabling advertising
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<ResponsePacketType.gap_set_mode: 58>] within 1.000000s
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a ResponsePacketType.gap_set_mode packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<ResponsePacketType.sm_set_bondable_mode: 51>] within 1.000000s
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a ResponsePacketType.sm_set_bondable_mode packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Stopping any outstanding GAP procedure
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<ResponsePacketType.gap_end_procedure: 61>] within 1.000000s
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a ResponsePacketType.gap_end_procedure packet: Device in wrong state
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Connecting to device at address 00:55:DA:B7:98:9C (timeout 5s)
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<ResponsePacketType.sm_set_bondable_mode: 51>] within 1.000000s
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a ResponsePacketType.sm_set_bondable_mode packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<ResponsePacketType.gap_connect_direct: 60>] within 1.000000s
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a ResponsePacketType.gap_connect_direct packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<EventPacketType.connection_status: 11>] within 5.000000s
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.connection_status packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Connection status: handle=0x0, flags=5, address=0xb'9c98b7da5500', connection interval=75.000000ms, timeout=1000, latency=0 intervals, bonding=0xff
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Connected to 00:55:DA:B7:98:9C
Is connected
DEBUG:pygatt.device:Looking up handle for characteristic 273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Fetching characteristics for connection 0
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<ResponsePacketType.attclient_find_information: 41>] within 1.000000s
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a ResponsePacketType.attclient_find_information packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<EventPacketType.attclient_procedure_completed: 17>] within 30.000000s
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found approved characteristic 00002a05-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found approved characteristic 00002a00-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found approved characteristic 00002a01-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found approved characteristic 00002a04-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found custom characteristic 273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found custom characteristic 273e0008-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found custom characteristic 273e0009-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found custom characteristic 273e000a-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found custom characteristic 273e000b-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found custom characteristic 273e0002-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found custom characteristic 273e0003-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found custom characteristic 273e0004-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found custom characteristic 273e0005-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found custom characteristic 273e0006-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found custom characteristic 273e0007-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found custom characteristic 273e000c-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
cDEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found custom characteristic 273e000d-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found custom characteristic 273e000e-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found custom characteristic 273e000f-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found custom characteristic 273e0010-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Found custom characteristic 273e0011-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_find_information_found packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_procedure_completed packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x00002a05-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x3
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x4
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x00002a00-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x7
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x00002a01-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x9
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x00002a04-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0xb
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 is handle 0xe
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0xf
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x273e0008-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 is handle 0x11
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x12
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x273e0009-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 is handle 0x14
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x15
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x273e000a-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 is handle 0x17
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x18
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x273e000b-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 is handle 0x1a
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x1b
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x273e0002-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 is handle 0x1d
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x1e
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x273e0003-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 is handle 0x20
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x21
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x273e0004-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 is handle 0x23
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x24
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x273e0005-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 is handle 0x26
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x27
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x273e0006-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 is handle 0x29
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x2a
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x273e0007-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 is handle 0x2c
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x2d
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x273e000c-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 is handle 0x2f
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x30
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x273e000d-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 is handle 0x32
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x33
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x273e000e-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 is handle 0x35
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x36
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x273e000f-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 is handle 0x38
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x39
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x273e0010-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 is handle 0x3b
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x3c
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic 0x273e0011-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 is handle 0x3e
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Characteristic descriptor 0x00002902-0000-1000-8000-00805f9b34fb is handle 0x3f
DEBUG:pygatt.device:Found <Characteristic uuid=273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 handle=14>
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<ResponsePacketType.attclient_attribute_write: 43>] within 1.000000s
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a ResponsePacketType.attclient_attribute_write packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<EventPacketType.attclient_procedure_completed: 17>] within 30.000000s
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_procedure_completed packet: Success
INFO:pygatt.device:Subscribed to uuid=273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.device:Looking up handle for characteristic 273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.device:Found <Characteristic uuid=273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 handle=14>
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<ResponsePacketType.attclient_attribute_write: 43>] within 1.000000s
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a ResponsePacketType.attclient_attribute_write packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<EventPacketType.attclient_procedure_completed: 17>] within 30.000000s
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_procedure_completed packet: Write not permitted
DEBUG:pygatt.device:Looking up handle for characteristic 273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.device:Found <Characteristic uuid=273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 handle=14>
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<ResponsePacketType.attclient_attribute_write: 43>] within 1.000000s
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a ResponsePacketType.attclient_attribute_write packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<EventPacketType.attclient_procedure_completed: 17>] within 30.000000s
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_procedure_completed packet: Write not permitted
DEBUG:pygatt.device:Looking up handle for characteristic 273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.device:Found <Characteristic uuid=273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 handle=14>
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<ResponsePacketType.attclient_attribute_write: 43>] within 1.000000s
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a ResponsePacketType.attclient_attribute_write packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<EventPacketType.attclient_procedure_completed: 17>] within 30.000000s
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.attclient_procedure_completed packet: Write not permitted
DEBUG:pygatt.device:Looking up handle for characteristic 273e0003-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358
DEBUG:pygatt.device:Found <Characteristic uuid=273e0003-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358 handle=32>
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<ResponsePacketType.attclient_attribute_write: 43>] within 1.000000s
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a EventPacketType.connection_disconnected packet: Success
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Received a ResponsePacketType.attclient_attribute_write packet: Not connected
DEBUG:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Expecting a response of one of [<EventPacketType.attclient_procedure_completed: 17>] within 30.000000s
Adapter stopped
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Stopping
INFO:pygatt.backends.bgapi.bgapi:Stopping receiver

Я не уверен, правильно ли я интерпретирую эту информацию, но мне кажется, что подписка работает и я получаю информацию, но обратный вызов не запускается?

Я попробовал решение здесь: pygatt: невозможно выполнить device.subscribe() добавив строки time.sleep() в мой код, но вывод не изменился.

Как я могу перевести свою программу bleak в pygatt и успешно подписаться с помощью pygatt?


person BeginnersMindTruly    schedule 25.07.2021    source источник
comment
У меня нет возможности узнать -› Это утверждение неверно, вы можете читать данные и без подписки. Когда я проверяю исходный код, я вижу, что если вы подпишетесь вы уведомлены log.info("Subscribed to uuid=%s", uuid), но я не вижу никакой обработки ошибок. Пожалуйста, добавьте вывод sudo btmon, чтобы мы могли продолжить отладку.   -  person Mr. Panda    schedule 25.07.2021
comment
В мрачном коде у вас есть response=False, а в pygattlib — wait_for_response=True. Вы запускаете это в Windows?   -  person ukBaz    schedule 25.07.2021
comment
@Mr.Panda спасибо за совет по ведению журнала, но я запускаю это на Mac OSX, поэтому команда btmon недоступна. @ukBaz, да, пробовал и с response = True, и с response = False в bleak. Оба работают. Ни один из них не работает для pygatt. Если это действительно проблема с ОС, я не уверен, почему я смогу подключиться, но не подписаться.   -  person BeginnersMindTruly    schedule 26.07.2021
comment
Глядя на пример уведомления для pygatt, он содержит оператор time.sleep() в цикле while True: для остановки выход потока. В примере есть комментарии, объясняющие более подробно, зачем это нужно. В вашем коде нет этого цикла while, поэтому я предполагаю, что это проблема, поскольку ваш код завершается до того, как он получит какие-либо уведомления.   -  person ukBaz    schedule 26.07.2021
comment
Спасибо, что поделились журналом, журналы очень помогают. Теперь я вижу, что вы можете получить дескрипторы уведомлений (0x2902) и подписаться на Subscribed to uuid=273e0001-4c4d-454d-96be-f03bac821358. Однако вы получаете Write is not permitted. Разрешение на запись определяется периферийным устройством (сервером), а не центральным устройством (клиентом). Но вы сказали, что точно такая же установка работала с Bleak, что сбивает с толку. Проверьте, позволяет ли ваше устройство BLE писать. Read и Write — это отдельные разрешения.   -  person Mr. Panda    schedule 26.07.2021
comment
@ukBaz С установленным циклом while он просто зависает в цикле, никогда не завершает работу и не получает информацию. Вывод просто Is connected и больше ничего. @Г-н. Панда: да, точно такая же установка работала с Bleak. Когда вы говорите, проверьте, позволяет ли ваше устройство BLE писать. Вы имеете в виду, что USB-ключ на моем Mac может записывать на подключенное периферийное устройство? Если да, то какие рекомендации, как проверить? Если вы имеете в виду подключенное периферийное устройство, я полагаю, что если код bleak работает, то периферия действительно разрешает запись, потому что я получаю желаемые ответы?   -  person BeginnersMindTruly    schedule 27.07.2021